Skip to Main Content

English for Academic Purposes

To support the EAP Foundational Courses at NYU Shanghai

Video Module: Source Genres

Background Information

Peer Reviewed

If a journal is peer reviewed (or refereed) or scholarly, its contents are reviewed and selected by a panel of experts (an authors' peers or recognized researchers in the field) . If the article meets strict guidelines, it may be accepted for publication. Peer reviewed journals hold more credibility and weight in academic circles than material taken from popular magazines.

How to Check if a Journal is Peer-Reviewed

To find out if a journal is peer-reviewed, try the following:

  • Journal's Website
    Go to the journal's website and look for a link to information about the journal, instructions for authors, or submitting an article, where you will find information about the peer review process at the journal.
     
  • Ulrichsweb is an easy to search source of detailed information on more than 300,000 journals of all types: academic and scholarly journals, e-journals, peer-reviewed titles, popular magazines, newspapers, newsletters. Enter the title of the journal.

    [Ulrichsweb likes to have the exact title - no shortcuts. Otherwise it may not locate the journal correctly].

Note the 'Refereed' symbol.

 

Hint: A common mistake is to think that Ulrichsweb will provide you with the articles from the journal. This is not the case! It is a great resource letting you know all about the journal, but not the contents of the journal.

Find Peer-Reviewed Articles in Databases

Most databases allow you to limit to peer reviewed, either by selecting an option before searching, or from the results screen.

For example, EBSCO Discovery Service (EDS) allows users to limit to peer reviewed/scholarly articles from the result screen. It is said all journals indexed in the Web of Science, ScienceDirect are scholarly and peer-reviewed! 

Databases